Data Source Brokerage:

    Continental Real Estate Group, Inc

    5 Manhattan Is, Wellesley Island, NY 13640

    $679,000

    194 days ago

    5 beds
    3 baths
    2,387 sq ft
    Built in
    Some financial estimates for this property, including market rent and property taxes are missing or deemed unreliable. As a result, the calculated metrics are incomplete. Simply enter your own assumptions to proceed with your analysis.

    About this property

    Escape to your Private Island Paradise! 5 Manhattan Island on the storied St Lawrence River, now available. Absolutely stunning residence and boat house, sitting on over half an acre. Known as "The Seth Green Cottage," the main house is believed to be the oldest standing home on the St Lawrence...

    Days on market

    194

    Property type

    Single family home

    Price per square foot

    $335

    Lot size

    -

    HOA fees

    -

    Neighborhood score

    3.5 / 5

    School score

    5 / 10

    Crime score

    2 / 10

    MLS Logo

    Listed By: Noah Taylor, 10401359495

    Source: Central New York Information Services, #S1591884, last updated on 8/8/2025

    Google maps

    Neighborhood

    5 / 10

    Alexandria Central Elementary School

    5 / 10

    Alexandria Central High School

    5 / 10

    Alexandria Central High School

    Provided by

    Sale comps

    Comparable sale properties
    Address
    Status
    Price
    Price / sq ft
    Distance
    Bed
    Bath
    Sq ft
    Year built
    21857 Lake Ave
    Wellesley Island, NY 13640

    Closed

    $1,600,000
    $662.25
    0.94mi
    5
    2
    2,416
    1950
    45748 Otter St
    Alexandria Bay, NY 13607

    Closed

    $399,000
    $185.41
    1.58mi
    5
    3
    2,152
    1921